Telkom Warns Icasa Against Giving Starlink Special Treatment

Telkom Wants South Africa to Ease BEE Rules for Starlink, Other Telecom Operators

South African telecommunications company Telkom has urged the country’s communications regulator to relax its black ownership requirements for all telecoms operators, arguing that the existing rules go beyond the provisions of the country’s empowerment laws and could discourage investment in network infrastructure.

In a submission to the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa), Telkom said its 2021 Equity Regulations impose additional Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) requirements that are not envisaged under the B-BBEE Act or the Information and Communications Technology (ICT) sector code.

The submission, filed in February as part of Icasa’s inquiry into new individual electronic communications network service (I-ECNS) licences, was published by the regulator.

Telkom, which is partly owned by the South African government, said the regulations had created uncertainty for telecommunications companies, increased compliance costs and potentially discouraged investment in the country’s networks.

The rules require individual licence holders to maintain at least 30 per cent ownership by historically disadvantaged groups throughout the duration of their licences, alongside a minimum Level 4 B-BBEE contributor status. The 30 per cent ownership threshold for historically disadvantaged groups is provided for under the Electronic Communications Act, while a separate black ownership requirement introduced by Icasa has been suspended.

β€œThe Equity Regulations introduce B-BBEE requirements that go beyond what is envisaged in the B-BBEE Act and the ICT sector codes,” Telkom said.

The company argued that Icasa’s framework places emphasis on minimum equity ownership without adequately recognising other ways of achieving economic empowerment.

It said empowerment objectives could also be advanced through skills development, local supply chain participation, infrastructure investment, research and innovation funding.

The position could have significant implications for Starlink, the satellite internet company owned by billionaire Elon Musk, which has faced regulatory hurdles over South Africa’s black ownership requirements.

Starlink has resisted calls to transfer 30 per cent ownership of its local operations to historically disadvantaged groups, a requirement that has complicated its efforts to secure the necessary licences to operate directly in the country.

In December 2025, Communications Minister Solly Malatsi issued a policy direction asking Icasa to urgently consider aligning its ownership regulations with the B-BBEE Act and the ICT sector code.

See also: Microsoft Presses Trump to Stop Planned Ban on Chinese Data Centre Technology

The proposed changes could allow multinational companies to meet empowerment obligations through equity-equivalent investment programmes (EEIPs), which involve investments in areas such as skills development, enterprise support and infrastructure rather than direct equity transfers.

However, Telkom said any changes must apply equally to existing operators and new entrants, including Starlink.

The company argued that satellite providers seeking to offer services directly to South African customers should obtain the relevant network, electronic communications service and spectrum licences and comply with the same licence conditions and social obligations imposed on existing operators.

It specifically named Starlink, Amazon Leo, Spacesail, Eutelsat OneWeb and Avanti Communications as companies that should be subject to the same regulatory requirements.

Telkom warned that allowing new entrants to operate under more favourable empowerment conditions could disadvantage established telecommunications companies that had already invested significant resources in meeting South Africa’s regulatory and ownership requirements.

It said such an approach could create a two-tier regulatory system in the country’s telecommunications industry.

The position is similar to that of the Association of Comms & Technology, which represents major operators including Telkom, Vodacom, MTN, Cell C, Rain and Liquid Intelligent Technologies. The industry group has supported the use of equity-equivalent programmes but has called for equal regulatory treatment of all operators.

Telkom also questioned whether issuing new I-ECNS licences would significantly improve competition in the market, arguing that their impact would likely be marginal.

Icasa, however, reached a different preliminary position in a discussion document published on October 30, proposing that prospective network operators should be allowed to apply directly for the licences.

About the Author

Cecilia Attah

Cecilia Attah is a tech analyst with a degree from Benue State University. She covers tech news and startups at TechRegard with a focus on how technology is transforming Africa and shaping the global landscape.